Becoming an Informed Birth Consumer (updated edition)

Sep3

“Birth is life’s central mystery. No one can predict how a birth may manifest…Our dominant culture is anything but ‘natural’ so it is no surprise that childbirth, even with the most natural lifestyle lived by an individual family, sometimes needs intervention and medical assistance. This is not to say that any one mother’s efforts to have a natural childbirth are futile. Just that birth is bigger than one’s personal desires.” –Jeannine Parvati Baker (in The Goddess Celebrates: An Anthology of Women’s Rituals, p. 215)

It’s Labor Day and it is also the start of Empowered Birth Awareness Week! A blog carnival is in full swing at The Guggie Daily and I’ve been having some thoughts about birth as a consumer issue. Very often, it appears to me that responsibility for birth outcomes is placed on the mother—if only she’d “gotten educated” she would have made “better choices.” Many people have a tendency or overlook or minimize the impact of the context in which she makes her choices. In that way, I appreciate Baker’s observation about that birth is bigger than one’s personal desires. That doesn’t mean that we can’t take vital steps to alter the larger culture of birth in which we make our choices, however, and one of those ways is to remember to think about birth as a consumer issue.

Though it may not often seem so, birth is a consumer issue. When speaking about their experiences with labor and birth, it is very common to hear women say, “they won’t let you do that here” (such as regarding active birth–moving during labor). They seem to have forgotten that they are customers receiving a service, hiring a service provider not a “boss.” If you went to a grocery store and were told at the entrance that you couldn’t bring your list in with you, that the expert shopping professional would choose your items for you, would you continue to shop in that store? No! If you hired a plumber to fix your toilet and he refused and said he was just going to work on your shower instead, would you pay him, or hire him to work for you again? No! In birth as in the rest of life, YOU are the expert on your own life. In this case, the expert on your body, your labor, your birth, and your baby. The rest are “paid consultants,” not experts whose opinions, ideas, and preferences override your own.

There are several helpful ways to become an informed birth consumer:

Read great books such as Henci Goer and Amy Romano’s new book Optimal Care in Childbirth or Pushed by Jennifer Block.
Hire an Independent Childbirth Educator (someone who works independently and is hired by you, not by a hospital). Some organizations that certify childbirth educators are Childbirth and Postpartum Professionals Association (CAPPA), BirthWorks, Birthing From Within, Lamaze, and Childbirth International. Regardless of the certifying organization, it is important to take classes from an independent educator who does not teach in a hospital. (I’m sure there are lots of great educators who work in hospitals, but in order to make sure you are not getting a “co-opted” class that is based on “hospital obedience training” rather than informed choice, an independent educator is a good bet.)
Consider hiring a doula—a doula is an experienced non-medical labor support provider who offers her continuous emotional and physical presence during your labor and birth. Organizations that train doulas include CAPPA, DONA, and Birth Arts.
Join birth organizations specifically for consumers such as Citizens for Midwifery or Birth Network National or International Cesarean Awareness Network.
Check to see if you have a local birth network in your own community or even start your own (I recently co-founded one in my town!)
Talk to other women in your community. Ask them what they liked about their births and about their care providers. Ask them what they wish had been different. Pay attention to their experiences and how they feel about their births. If they are dissatisfied, scarred, unhappy, and disappointed, don’t do what they did.
Ask your provider questions. Ask lots of questions. Make sure your philosophies align. If it isn’t a match, switch care providers. This is not the time for misplaced loyalty. Your baby will only be born once, don’t dismiss concerns your may have over the care you receive or decide that you can make different choices “next time.”
Find a care provider that supports Lamaze’s Six Healthy Birth Practices and is willing to speak with you seriously about them:

These care practices are evidence-based and form an excellent backbone for a solid, mother and baby friendly birth plan.

Why “evidence-based care” though?

Because maternity care that is based on research and evidence for best practice is not just a nice idea or a bonus. It isn’t just about having a “good birth.” Evidence-based care is what mothers and babies deserve and what all birthing mothers should be able to expect! Here is a great summary of pregnancy and birthing practices that the evidence backs up:

Remember that birth is YOURS—it is not the exclusive territory of the doctor, the hospital, the nurse, the midwife, the doula, or the childbirth educator. These people are all paid consultants—hired by you to help you (and what helps you, helps your baby!).

“As long as birth- metaphorically or literally-remains an experience of passively handing over our minds and our bodies to male authority and technology, other kinds of social change can only minimally change our relationship to ourselves, to power, and to the world outside our bodies” – Adrienne Rich (Of Woman Born p185)

Birth class handouts

Can I really expect to have a great birth? (updated edition)

What to Expect When You Go to the Hospital for a Natural Birth

Active Birth in the Hospital

The Illusion of Choice

Musings on Story, Experience, & Choice…

—

This post is updated from a previous edition.

Book Review: Pushing for Midwives

Aug29

Book Review: Pushing for Midwives: Homebirth Mothers and the Reproductive Rights Movement
by Christa Craven
Paperback: 232 pages
Publisher: Temple University Press; 1 edition (October 28, 2010)
ISBN-13: 978-1439902202

Reviewed by Molly Remer, Talk Birth

Mainstream feminist groups have been slow to recognize the right to reproduce along with the right to be free from reproducing. A focus of the second-wave women’s movement was shaking off motherhood as what solely defined womanhood. So perhaps there has been a reluctance to watch over the process that makes women mothers. –Jennifer Block quoted in Pushing for Midwives

Framed as a health policy concern, Pushing for Midwives assesses the homebirth movement and midwifery activism in the context of the reproductive rights movement. The focus of the book is on legislation in Virginia, but is still of relevance and interest to activists from other states. Craven also tackles complicated topics that are often ignored in homebirth and midwifery texts, addressing issues of race, privilege, and socioeconomic status and the impact on access to care. She also takes a solid look at issues of political and religious diversity within the homebirth activist community.

Written in a densely academic style evocative of a dissertation, Pushing for Midwives, became tedious and dry in places and took a long time to finish reading. The very narrow focus on Virginia, while still applicable to other states, became tiresome by the final chapters.

I particularly enjoyed Craven’s exploration of the history of consumer activism in midwifery as well as the consideration of homebirth in the larger context of women’s health activism. I appreciated her exploration of the feminist movement and how it has historically neglected issues of birth advocacy and reform, while also looking the current relationship between feminism and midwifery activism, particularly how birth advocates choose to self-identify. Women’s health activists and midwifery advocates will likely find a lot of food for thought in the pages of Pushing for Midwives.

—

Disclosures: I received a complimentary copy of this book for review purposes.

Amazon affiliate links included in book title and image.

Can I really expect to have a great birth? (updated edition)

Aug22

“Given my limited situation, can I really expect to have a great birth today?” For the woman who asked me this question a homebirth, a birth center, a midwife, and a doula were all not remotely feasible options. My answer to her question is a qualified “yes!” and it really got me thinking about ways to help yourself have a great birth when your overall choices are limited. In fact, there is a long list of ideas of things that may help contribute to a great birth!

Choose your doctor carefully—don’t wait for “the next birth” to find a compatible caregiver. Don’t dismiss uneasiness with your present care provider. As Pam England says, “ask questions before your chile is roasted.” A key point is to pick a provider whose words and actions match (i.e. You ask, “how often do you do episiotomies?” The response, “only when necessary”—if “necessary” actually means 90% of the time, it is time to find a different doctor!). Also, if you don’t want surgery, don’t go to a surgeon (that perhaps means finding a family physician who attends births, rather than an OB, or, an OB with a low cesarean rate).
If there are multiple hospitals in your area, choose the one with the lowest cesarean rate (not the one with the nicest wallpaper or nicest postpartum meal). Hospitals—even those in the same town—vary widely on their policies and the things they “allow” (i.e. amount of separation of mother and baby following birth, guidelines on eating during labor, etc.) Try checking with Cesareanrates.com for local information!
When you get the hospital, ask to have a nurse who likes natural birth couples. My experience is that there are some nurses like this in every hospital—she’ll want you for a patient and you’ll want her, ask who she is! If possible, ask your doctor, hospital staff, or office staff who the nurses are who like natural birth—then you’ll have names to ask for in advance.
Put a sign at eye level on the outside of your door that reads, “I would like a natural birth. Please do not offer pain medications.” (It is much easier to get on with your birth if you don’t have someone popping in to ask when you’re “ready for your epidural!” every 20 minutes.)
You might want to check out either or both of these two books: Homebirth in the Hospital and/or Natural Hospital Birth
Work on clear and assertive communication with your doctor and reinforce your preferences often—don’t just mention something once and assume s/he will remember. If you create a birth plan, have the doctor sign it and put it in your chart (then it is more like “doctor’s orders” than “wishes”). Do be aware that needing to do this indicates a certain lack of trust that may mean you are birthing in the wrong setting for you! Birth is not a time in a woman’s life when she should have to fight for anything! You deserve quality care that is based on your unique needs, your unique birthing, and your unique baby! Do not let a birth plan be a substitute for good communication.
Two resources I particularly enjoy that shake up the notion of a birth plan are, 1. the birth as a labyrinth metaphor from Birthing from Within and 2. this article about how does one really PLAN for birth.
When making a birth plan, use the Six Healthy Birth Practices as a good, solid foundation.
Cultivate a climate of confidence in your life.
Once in labor, stay home for a long time. Do not go to the hospital too early—the more labor you work through at home, the less interference you are likely to run into. When I say “a long time,” I mean that you’ve been having contractions for several hours, that they require your full attention, that you are no longer talking and laughing in between them, that you are using “coping measures” to work with them (like rocking, or swaying, or moaning, or humming), and that you feel like “it’s time” to go in. If you’re worried about knowing when you’re really in labor, check out this post: how do I know if I’m really in labor?
Ask for the blanket consent forms in advance and modify/initial them as needed—this way you are truly giving “informed consent,” not hurriedly signing anything and everything that is put in front of you because you are focused on birthing instead of signing.
Have your partner read a book like The Birth Partner, or Fathers at Birth, and practice the things in the book together. I frequently remind couples in my classes that “coping skills work best when they are integrated into your daily lives, not ‘dusted off’ for use during labor.”
Practice prenatal yoga—I love the Lamaze “Yoga for Your Pregnancy” DVD—specifically the short, 5-minute, “Birthing Room Yoga” segment. I teach it to all of my birth class participants.
Use the hospital bed as a tool, not as a place to lie down (see my How to Use a Hospital Bed without Lying Down handout)
If you feel like you “need a break” in the hospital, retreat to the bathroom. People tend to leave us alone in the bathroom and if you feel like you need some time to focus and regroup, you may find it there. Also, we know how to relax our muscles when sitting on the toilet, so spending some time there can actually help baby descend.
Use the “broken record” technique—if asked to lie down for monitoring, say “I prefer to remain sitting” and continue to reinforce that preference without elaborating or “arguing.”
During monitoring DO NOT lie down! Sit on the edge of the bed, sit on a birth ball near the bed, sit in a rocking chair or regular chair near the bed, kneel on the bed and rotate your hip during the monitoring—you can still be monitored while in an upright position (as long as you are located very close to the bed). Check out the post Active Birth in the Hospital for some additional ideas.
Bring a birth ball with you and use it—sit near the bed if you need to (can have an IV, be monitored, etc. while still sitting upright on the ball). Birth balls have many great uses for an active, comfortable birth!
Learn relaxation techniques that you can use no matter what. I have a preference for active birth and movement based coping strategies, but relaxation and breath-based strategies cannot be taken away from you no matters what happens. The book Birthing from Within has lots of great breath-awareness strategies. I also have several good relaxation handouts and practice exercises that I am happy to email to people who would like them. One of my favorites is: Centering for Birth.
Use affirmations to help cultivate a positive, joyful, welcoming attitude.
Read good books and cultivate confidence and trust in your body, your baby, your inherent birth wisdom.
Take a good independent birth class (not a hospital based class).
Before birth, research and ask questions when things are suggested to you (an example, having an NST [non-stress test] or gestational diabetes testing). A good place to review the evidence behind common forms of care during pregnancy, labor, and birth is at Childbirth Connection, where they have the full text of the book A Guide to Effective Care in Pregnancy and Childbirth available for free download (this contains a summary of all the research behind common forms of care during pregnancy, labor, and birth and whether the evidence supports or does not support those forms of care).
When any type of routine intervention is suggested (or assumed) during pregnancy or labor, remember to use your “BRAIN”—ask about the Benefits, the Risks, the Alternatives, check in with your Intuition, what would happen if you did Nothing/or Now Decide.
Along those same lines, if an intervention is aggressively promoted while in the birth room, but it is not an emergency (let’s say a “long labor” and augmentation with Pitocin is suggested, you and baby are fine and you feel okay with labor proceeding as it is, knowing that use of Pitocin raises your chances of having further interventions, more painful contractions, or a cesarean), you can ask “Can you guarantee that this will not harm my baby? Can I have in writing that this intervention will not hurt my baby? Please show me the evidence behind this recommendation.”
If all your friends have to share is horror stories about how terrible birth was, don’t do what they did.
Look at ways in which you might be sabotaging yourself—ask yourself hard and honest questions (i.e. if you greatest fear is having a cesarean, why are you going to a doctor with a 50% cesarean rate? “Can’t switch doctors, etc.” are often excuses or easy ways out if you start to dig below the surface of your own beliefs. A great book to help you explore these kinds of beliefs and questions is Mother’s Intention: How Belief Shapes Birth by Kim Wildner. You might not always want to hear the answers, but it is a good idea to ask yourself difficult questions!
Believe you can do it and believe that you and your baby both deserve a beautiful, empowering, positive birth!

I realize that some of these strategies may seem unnecessarily defensive and even possibly antagonistic—I wanted to offer a “buffet” of possibilities. Take what works for you and leave the rest!

I posted on my Facebook page asking for additional thoughts and suggestions and I appreciated this one from doula and educator, Rebecca:

“I think I’d tell people to stop closing doors on themselves you know? Stop making assumptions about what is possible and be open to creating new possibilities – maybe not perfect and exact but inviting in opportunity. No money doesn’t mean no doula in most cases.”

She’s right! A lot of doulas-in-training will offer free birth services, many doulas and midwives do barter arrangements or other trades, and many non-traditional birth professionals also have sliding scale rates.

Great births are definitely possible, in any setting, and there are lots of things you can do to help make a great birth a reality!

—

This post was revised (from this one) to participate in… And the Empowered Birth Awareness Blog Carnival!

Birth Customs

Aug14

“Pay attention to the pregnant woman! There is no one as important as she!”

(Chagga saying, Uganda)

The book Mamatoto is a look at birth in a variety of cultures (including the US) that was published by The Body Shop in 1991. Even though it is “old” it isn’t really dated since it is a brief overview of different customs and rituals and so forth and not a lot of statistics. There are a lot of absolutely fabulous (and fascinating) pictures and illustrations and these are the highlight of the book. Each chapter is followed by a “black page” of “facts you don’t want to know” about such things are reproductive health care policies in Romania and things like that.

One of the things that struck me about this book was that there is little distinction made between the customs of other cultures and the customs of the US. For example:

“People in Tibet believe that whether or not labour is due, a child won’t come out into the world unless the star under which it’s destined to be born is shining. Western medicine has developed a way of starting labour artificially, by injecting into a woman’s blood a simulation of the hormone oxytocin, which triggers contractions. For several years during this century, an unusual number of women laboured between the convenient hours of nine and five on weekdays…As the Malaysians say, a baby is like a fruit; it will be born when it’s ripe.”

I absolutely love seeing Western culture put into the proper context like this. Too often we see our way as THE way and forget that much of what the dominant culture views as normal for birth is not necessarily truly normal, but is instead an artifact of, or custom of, our culture. Viewed from a distance, the routines of birth in America are just interesting customs—in Tibet, born when the proper star is out, in the US, born when artificial hormones are injected…

(Since first reading this, I use the baby is like a fruit quote regularly.)

I may not be explaining myself clearly, but I find this distance in perspective refreshing and interesting. It reminds me of the work of anthropologist Robbie Davis Floyd whose book Birth as an American Rite of Passage explores the “ritual” elements of hospital birth in America and compares and contrasts the “technocratic” model of care with a holistic, woman-centered model of care (an example of which would be the midwives model of care). She asserts that there are many elements of hospital births that serve as rituals to reinforce the technocratic model (rather than to serve actual purposes, but instead to send cultural messages as well as to initiate the baby into the technocratic model). Examples of ritual elements include putting on a hospital gown, riding in a wheelchair, and having a routine IV. These elements serve to enculturate the woman and baby into a particular model–a ritual function–rather than an individually appropriate method of care.

Another example from Mamatoto that I enjoyed is as follows:

“‘Home birth’ can mean different things to different people. It can mean a bedroom, dimly lit and scented with myrr; a sweatbath perched on a Guatemalan hillside, or a birthing pool in an English flat; a warm fireside in a Himalayan kitchen; the packed-snow sleeping platform of an Inuit igloos; or a one-room shack in Jamaica, with a washing line dividing the family bed and the children waiting on the other side for a first glance at the baby who will be held up for them to see. When a woman gives birth at home, she and her family have a degree of control over the event; it’s their domain.”

In short, at home the family is in their own personal culture rather than having to adapt to the customs, culture, and “ritual elements” of an out-of-home environment.

When I think about American birth customs and culture, the first thing that comes to mind is this potent illustration from Mothering Magazine’s powerful article Cesarean Birth in a Culture of Fear, which was then published in booklet form by Childbirth Connection:

In this image we see a woman immersed in the hospital birth culture found in many hospitals in the US.* She is hooked up to a potential of 16 different attachments. When I see this image, I instantly see why women might not want to “be martyrs” and thus go ahead and have any medications offered to them. It can be very difficult to stand in her personal power and embrace her own body’s rhythms and rituals when she is literally strapped down in this manner. I also think of this quote:

“Since beliefs affect physiologic functions, how women and men discuss the process of pregnancy and birth can have a negative or positive effect on the women that are involved in the discussion. Our words are powerful and either reinforce or undermine the power of women and their bodies.”–Debra Bingham

—

*Note: I am fully aware that this may not be what birth looked like in your hospital, but I’m speaking generically about many hospitals in the nation.

Modified from a post originally posted at Citizens for Midwifery

Amazon affiliate links included in book titles.

Controversies in Breastfeeding

Aug1

If you get a chance to attend one of his presentations, don’t miss it! In this slide, Dr. Jack explains that he disagrees strongly with the notion that a baby that has lost 10% of its birthweight needs to be supplemented.

Just in time for the start of World Breastfeeding Week, here is part 4 of my CAPPA re-cap series!

This post is a companion to my CAPPA re-cap post about the impact of birth practices on breastfeeding. Dr. Newman’s keynote session about Controversies in Breastfeeding was actually given before his breakout about birth and breastfeeding, but for the chronological value, it made sense to me to put up the birth post first.

As I already shared, in Newman’s perspective we have a huge problem in that many medical care providers do not recognize the critical importance of breastfeeding. Newman also emphasized that there are many people who don’t know squat about breastfeeding and breastmilk and don’t feel like they need to learn anything before they start doing studies and writing papers about it.

Why is hard to study breastmilk?

Because…there is no such thing as “standard” breastmilk. It is a physiological fluid and varies from person to person. We DO NOT have to prove that breastfeeding is better than formula. Those comparison studies are unnecessary.

Some great stuff from Dr. Newman’s presentation about controversies:

The exclusively breastfed, well-gaining 5 month old is getting only, at most, 10-15% more milk than the exclusively breastfeeding, well-gaining 1 month old, even though the 5 month old is twice as heavy. Baby continues to gain weight steadily even though it is not “getting enough” compared to its formula fed counterpart. (put that in your pipe and smoke it–yep, he really then said that ;-D)
Colostrum has 100,000-5,000,000 leukocytes per ml–that is more than blood. (i.e. colostrum has more white blood cells in it than your actual blood has in it!)
Colostrum and formula are the same in the following ways: both are liquid.
Breastmilk does not need to supply vitamin D (makes no sense to describe breastmilk as “deficient in” or “lacking” vitamin D).
With regard to the high incidence of reflux being diagnosed in babies—his response to why so high is, “because [most] doctors don’t know anything about breastfeeding.”
We learn one thing when we hear that the mother has been told to feed her baby X number of minutes per side—>the person telling her this does not understand breastfeeding.
There are no such thing as “flat nipples”–women have normal nipples. We live in a bottle feeding culture that makes us assume that if a mother does not have nipples that stick out like a bottle nipple, the nipples are flat (**Molly’s own note–we also live in a culture where 75-90% of women have epidurals during labor which can contribute to edema in the breast and the accompanying appearance of flat nipples).

And, there should be no controversy about formula feeding vs. breastfeeding. If you actually look at the biochemistry of breastmilk you would know there is no comparison. No controversy. (with a laugh after this he added, “pediatricians are simple folk” ;-D)

In that plainspoken way I found so refreshing, Dr. Jack also pointed out that formula feeding is missing one more thing: breastfeeding. That’s right. Society thinks that bottle feeding is the “same”–it isn’t. Breastfeeding is an intimate relationship. He also pointed out that, “people will lie, lie, lie to sell products.” (see ad to right)

Finally, he explained that this mechanization of breastfeeding (through things like test weighing and nipple shields and timed feedings) will cause more and more mothers to abandon breastfeeding and then she’ll say, ‘we tried everything and it just didn’t work.’ Yes, we did “try everything,” everything to make her not succeed. (And, then she’ll write an article about it complaining about “what’s wrong with breastfeeding.”)

—

Handouts from Dr. Newman are available here. One I’ve used recently is How to Know a Health Professional is not Supportive of Breastfeeding.

I address other systemic influences on breastfeeding in Breastfeeding as an Ecofeminist Issue

The Impact of Birth on Breastfeeding

Jul31

Just in time for the start of World Breastfeeding Week, here is part 3 of my CAPPA re-cap series!

…they want you to believe it’s their power, not yours…They stick needles into you so you won’t hear anything, you might as well be a dead pig, your legs are up in metal frames, they bend over you, technicians, mechanics, butchers, students, clumsy or sniggering, practicing on your body, they take your baby out with a fork like a pickle out of a jar.

–Margaret Atwood in her novel Surfacing (opening quote of Dr. Jack’s presentation at the 2012 CAPPA conference)

As I mentioned, my favorite part of the CAPPA conference was hearing Dr. Jack Newman speak about controversies in breastfeeding (see next post) and then about the impact of birth on breastfeeding (breakout session). He was an amazing speaker. Very straightforward and almost blunt as well as funny and fast-paced. I really feel glad to have had the chance to see him in person after years of being familiar with his materials.

The notion of the birth-breastfeeding continuum isn’t new to me, having actually published articles about it previously, however Dr. Newman’s phrasing, descriptions, and reminders was just so perfect that it left me feeling even more enthused about the inextricable link between birth and breastfeeding. It is a biologic continuum that nature does not see distinct events—baby is born and goes to breast, it is part of the same event. Drawing on Diane Wiessinger’s work, Dr. Newman explained

With animal births: following a normal birth, infant feeding just…happens. Following an interventionist birth, the mother rejects the baby and there is no nursing at all.

In some hospitals, separation of mother and baby is routine as a way to “prevent” postpartum mood disorders. Dr. Jack’s own theory was that perhaps human mothers turn this “rejection” against themselves and it shows up as a postpartum mood disorder.

Babies NEED and expect to be with their mothers after birth. It is of critical importance. As I shared via Facebook, Dr. Jack explained this:

Know how much an incubator costs now? $50,000. Why don’t we just give half of that money to the mother and put the baby skin to skin on mother’s chest?

And, this gem:

“Our hospital births break every rule in the mammalian list of mother-baby necessities.” –Dr. Newman

He also noted that if baby is put skin-to-skin on mother immediately after birth regardless of original intention, the pair will breastfeed. It is biologically programmed.

Why do hospital births break the rules?

Because, as Dr. Newman explained we have a big, big problem in that HCPs do not recognize the critical importance of breastfeeding. He also repeatedly emphasized (in a very funny way) that there are many people who don’t know squat about breastfeeding and breastmilk and don’t feel like they need to learn anything before they start doing studies and writing papers about it.

Dr. Newman also emphasized the important point that the burden of proof rests upon those who promote an intervention! He was speaking with regard to recommending formula supplementation, but I strongly believe it applies to any birth practice. So simple and yet so profound. One example that he shared that is familiar to birth advocates is that lying down for electronic fetal monitoring is a position of comfort for the care provider, NOT for the mother.

And, he made this excellent point: “All medical interventions, even when necessary, decrease the mother’s sense of control, and increase her sense of her ‘body not being up to the task.” Again, the burden of proof rests on those who promote the intervention, not vice versa.

As I’ve touched on several times before, IV fluids that are commonly administered during labor may increase the baby’s birth weight, leading the baby to be more likely to experience the dreaded 10% weight loss (“totally bogus, by the way”). Also as I’ve noted before, IV fluids lead to significant maternal fluid retention which contributes to edema in the nipples and areolas and then…the dreaded “flat nipples.” The more fluid a mother gets in labor, the more a baby “loses” after birth!

Including the same picture as in my other post, because it is in this picture that Dr. Jack is specifically talking about his next point:

I disagree strongly with this statement:

‘Typically, loss of = or >10% of birth weight in the first few days suggests dehydration and the need to consider supplementation.’

He goes on to note that what is necessary is NOT supplementation but to help the mother and baby breastfeed well. The real question when it comes to newborn weight loss is, “is the mother-baby breastfeeding well?”

Newman also addressed something birth advocates are familiar with, the fact that epidural anesthesia can cause maternal fever. This leads to an infant sepsis workup and antibiotics and usually means separation of mother and baby. Here we again experience the failure of many medical care providers to recognize the importance of breastfeeding as beyond just a feeding method. Breastfeeding protects the baby–this is what most hospitals do not understand.

Of interventions that undermine breastfeeding, Dr. Jack pointed to Demerol (meperidine) as the “worst of the lot,” with newborns experiencing sedation and many of them not sucking at all. He also pointed out that all interventions increase the risk of cesarean section, which leads to increased discomfort for mothers and less willingness to breastfeed and increased likelihood of mother-baby separation.

The importance of skin-to-skin contact

Babies easily find their way to the unwashed nipple. And, given baby’s inborn feeding behaviors and instincts, it seems clear that, “if the baby expresses his or her choice, the baby would choose the breast.” (with regard to breastfeeding as maternal “choice”)

Not putting baby skin to skin with the mother, “increases the risk of hypoglycaemia significantly…Isn’t skin to skin contact a less invasive preventative measure than giving formula?” Newman then points out that most often we see “skin to blankets” which keeps baby from showing they’re ready to feed, doesn’t stimulate milk supply, and leads to engorgement which is not normal.

And, at the end he emphasized that when it comes to birth and breastfeeding, all too often WE MESS IT UP by meddling with the biological processes and rhythms of the mother-baby relationship.

—

For more about controversies in breastfeeding, check out my next post.

Handouts from Dr. Newman are available here. One I’ve used recently is How to Know a Health Professional is not Supportive of Breastfeeding.

I’ve written about the birth-breastfeeding continuum and about some other systemic influences on breastfeeding in breastfeeding as an ecofeminist issue.

Epigentics, Breastfeeding + Diet, and Prenatal Stress

Jul27

This post is part one of my CAPPA Re-Cap series.

CAPPA linchpins Laurel Wilson and Tracy Wilson Peters are co-authors of a new book, The Greatest Pregnancy Ever, that focuses on the depth, intensity, and value of the MotherBaby bond. As I noted, I listened to Laurel talk about Bridging the Nutrition Gap and to Tracy speak about the “accidental parent.” In both, they addressed the biological wisdom that mothers possess and of the deeply interconnected nature of the maternal relationship.

Laurel reminded us that there is a brain in our gut, essentially. This brain literally tells us how we should be feeling our emotions, based on the nutrition that we’re putting into our bodies. She discussed epigenetics–a term meaning literally “above the gene”—explaining that this is the “translator that ‘reads’ the book of instructions from our genome.” The translator tells the body to turn on or off the genes we’ve inherited from our parents. Epigenetics is essentially the environment–those things in our environment that influence our biology. Laurel pointed out enthusiastically that we want to create an excellent “translator” for our children. She also emphasized repeatedly that one important job of the placenta is to “train” the baby for the environment it will be experiencing. This is why prenatal diet matters, it is helping to prepare the baby to thrive in the environment into which it will be born. So, chronic stress leads to a stressful womb environment, which leads to a baby that is biologically primed to be born into a stressful postnatal environment. Mother’s body primes baby’s body for success in that environment. As I listened to her speak and discuss the things we’ve learned from science about genetics and how our bodies function, I kept thinking: science can do a lot, it can do wonderful things. Mother’s body can do even more… And, isn’t that just cool?!

So, what’s going on in the maternal habitat?

One important point Laurel made about prenatal diets was that prenatal diets high in hydrogenated oils predispose mamas to postpartum moods disorders. She said this is because hydrogenated oils essentially “leach” EFA’s out of the mother’s system.

She also noted that mice up to three generations are affected with PCOS by BPA and phthalates (in food packaging. Our food is literally making us sick). These influence change the endocrine system and are connected with reduced sociality and community engagement.

Laurel explained too that no artificial sweeteners are considered safe for pregnant women and that stevia too is linked to epigentic damage. She suggested using honey and molasses as sweeteners if needed.

One tip that I found funny, basic, but so true with regard to choosing healthy foods is to make sure to choose to eat foods that will rot!

In Tracy’s talk she passionately affirmed that we have to eliminate chronic stress from pregnant women’s lives because she is laying an emotional and physical foundation for another person’s life. This matters! Babies are feeling before they are thinking and we are designed to live in the environment we are being born into.

Also remember, babies don’t need to be in nurseries–they need to be with their mothers. This MATTERS!

DVD Review: Expecting More

May25

DVD Review: Expecting More
Prenatal exercise program
Two disc set, 230 minutes
$39.95
Daily Sweat, 2011

http://sarahaley.com/about/expecting-more/

Reviewed by Molly Remer, Talk Birth

Fun, energetic, and challenging, Expecting More is a prenatal exercise program developed and hosted by prenatal fitness expert, Sara Haley. Developed and filmed during her own pregnancy, Sara created Expecting More out of her desire to offer a prenatal fitness experience that is vigorous and more fast-paced than the routines typically offered by prenatal exercise videos. Offering lots of encouragement to stay “sexy and strong” during pregnancy, the DVD set of two discs includes six different workouts:

Synergy: Create SYNERGY within your body by alternating between Sara’s signature cardio and strength exercises.

Sweat Sport: Discover your inner athlete as you execute sports drills in a cardio session with modifications for all stages of pregnancy.

Sweat Funk: Embrace your sexy pregnant body as you get your FUNK on with hot dance cardio moves.Sweat Strong Down: Sculpt your body DOWN on the floor in a safe and effective way that supports your core and your baby.

Sweat Strong Up: Stand UP and sculpt your body in all the right places to keep you sexy and strong during your pregnancy.

Salutations: Designed to sooth and calm, you’ll breath, stretch, and move with this expression of good will to your baby and your body, your SALUTATION.

The Salutations portion is clearly inspired by both dance and yoga and is based on standing exercises that are less vigorous than the other workouts on the discs, but still very lively and movement oriented. Expecting More is led by a cute, contemporary fitness trainer with a pleasant voice. During some of the workouts, two additional women perform modified versions of the exercises in the background so that it is easy for women with different needs to follow along. I appreciated that the DVD contains lots of reminders about the importance of listening to your body. Expecting More presents exercise as a fun and engaged time to be close to your baby and to pay attention to your body and I feel like this approach contributes to a healthy, active attitude towards giving birth as well.

—

Disclosure: I received a complimentary copy of this DVD for review purposes.

I am a Midwife Campaign

May22

MANA has a great educational campaign going on right now called I am a Midwife. The campaign involves a series of short videos released once a week about a variety of topics. More than just a general education campaign, each video includes a variety of different women–midwives, mothers, public health activists, maternity care activists, authors—speaking out on important topics in maternity care. Each woman also identifies, “I am a Midwife.” This week’s video is about health disparities in maternity care, which is a very important and too-often ignored topic. It raises the concern that African American women and their babies are more likely to die than their Caucasian counterparts even when other variables are equalized (i.e. same socioeconomic status, same education, etc.) and moves into wider discussions about racism and the treatment of minority group members. It then focuses on the value and role of midwifery care in addressing these concerns.

As MANA states in relationship to this campaign: “For midwives, sharing is daring. We dare to challenge the status quo. We dare to speak up for women’s innate wisdom in pregnancy and birth. We dare to assert that there is a better way for our babies to be born. And we dare to insist that birth belongs to families.”

Absolutely! The I am a Midwife public education campaign is extremely powerful. I have to confess that when it originally launched, I didn’t personally make time to watch the videos right away, somehow assuming that they were “generic” videos with a “rah, midwives!” type of message. Don’t make the same mistake I did. These are quality videos with important messages, powerful voices, and essential education and information. You will definitely learn something from watching them!

The videos aren’t only of use to birth professionals, when I teach community organizing at the college level I show videos like this as examples of activism strategies. In fact, for the final exam in that course I show the Crisis in the Crib video about infant mortality and disparities from the Office of Minority Health’s A Healthy Baby Begins With You campaign. This MANA video could be an interesting follow-up addition to the video I already use. As a related side note, during this class I also show footage from The Doula Story, a project by the Georgia Campaign for Adolescent Teen Pregnancy Prevention (whose program director I heard speak at the CAPPA conference in NC in 2010—she was amazing!). So, people do not leave my class without having heard of doulas and midwives and their relationship to community health. Go me and my mad birth activist skills! ;-D

Birth Plan Item #1: Leave My Cervix Inside My Body!

Feb11

Some time ago I read several articles in Midwifery Today about birth in the Ukraine. Apparently, it is a routine practice immediately postpartum to use two “shoe horn” shaped devices to pull the cervix out of the woman’s body to examine. Yes, I think that warrants repeating–manually pulling out the cervix to look at! (no pain medications). This is so patently horrible and unnecessary that I had a visceral response to reading about it–my uterus hurt.

U.S. maternity care routines

However, as I reflected on my reaction, I began to wonder if the practice is any more strange or disturbing that some U.S. maternity care routines? I still feel like cervix-pulling-out ranks pretty high on the horrible factor, but I also recognize that it is filtered through my cultural lens of what I’m used to—“normal” (i.e. culturally acceptable) birth practices in the U.S. (such as Pitocin injection immediately following most normal births regardless of indication and so on and so forth). We have any number of questionable medical care practices in this country too, but because I’m used to them they register as “normal.” Of course, this doesn’t mean I approve of them or fail to notice that they are not evidence-based, but I accept them as possible occurrences and I’m certainly not surprised to read about them over and over again, or shocked when my clients experience them during their births.

One of the articles was about birth in a Ukrainian “birth house” and the other was a composite of observations about birth in the Ukraine in general. Sometimes there is a tendency amongst midwifery supporters to romanticize birth and midwifery care in other countries and to vilify the U.S.—if you are a Ukrainian woman, this is clearly misplaced!

My first thought when reading the essays was, “Wow! The U.S. system isn’t so terrible after all!” But then, I tried to imagine the U.S. birth culture seen through completely fresh eyes, as I had just viewed the cervix-pulling technique. How would facets of hospital birth care in the U.S. appear to me if I was just hearing about them for the first time? As gross human rights violations?

Though I cannot make it have the same raw emotional and physical shock to me as cervix-pulling-out, I can only imagine how an episiotomy might sound to my imaginary fresh eyes: “then the doctor took some scissors and cut through the skin and muscles at the base of the woman’s vagina.” Or, the same with the not uncommon addition of, “as she begged ‘please don’t cut me! No!'”

I also read with sadness and dismay about the emotional maltreatment of Ukrainian women in labor and how (in hospitals) they are frequently denied the companionship of their husbands. Is this really more awful than women being coerced into unnecessary cesareans or even more basic, being denied food and drink throughout their labors? No, not really, just less familiar.

What do all women deserve?

While it is nice to recognize that there are things that women birthing in U.S. hospitals can be very grateful for, there is not an official continuum or hierarchy of “better” bad things to happen to birthing women regardless of country of residence. Humanized care is humanized care. Women worldwide deserve a safe environment, a respectful caregiver, continuous emotional support, physically responsive care, evidence-based medicine, and to have their cervixes and uteruses left inside their bodies.

—

(P.S. In case anyone is interested, “cervices” or “cervixes” and “uteri” or “uteruses” are both acceptable plurals)